This page should not have been necessary but there exists in town just a very few nasty people who, for reasons that are apparent only to themselves, feel no remorse any time they decide to defame others. This "defense" exists ONLY because they have made it necessary. The following contains a public letter I made available (in 2004) to anyone with "doubts" about the mission, goals, and the current and future physical implementation of the work of this Foundation. To illustrate the longevity of such defamation, I again heard portions of the same story from someone else as recently as in 2010. And although the Foundation (now, in 2010) has an even longer history of grants (see Our grantees), some people still believe the worst of what they've heard.
the following was written by me, Michael Wein, in 2004 - QUOTE
Money is being taken from poor children. I now know WHO is doing this and what I intend to do about it. Because the problem and answer is quite long, I summarize it all under the following subject headings:
What and who is taking this money?
Gossip and the malicious or merely ignorant gossipers. Gossip is rampant in SMA and it is hurting the most defenseless people among us. I have heard malicious gossip about so many of all of us; and the gossipers are causing untold hurt. What is being said is too often untrue but enough people not only believe it but pass it on, adding their own embellishments. What I have heard about myself (and I will tell you what is being said below) is not really hurting me but it is harming the children of San Miguel who can not defend themselves. Absent the results of this gossip, these children would receive the benefits from the $2,900,000 endowment that is intended to fund the major part of the mission of my Foundation
By this I mean that both the MPW Charitable Foundation and myself have been defamed so much and so often that some local organizations (with missions intended to help the very people my Foundation also attempts to help) do not ask us for grants. This is because they have been falsely led to believe that they will not receive any grants. As a consequence, they are thereby losing both current and future grant money that at this time is still very much available and that would help their beneficiaries, mostly the women and children of San Miguel.
What are the details of this problem?
There has been so many lies that cause misunderstandings about the MPWCFoundation and I wish to clear this up. In a town where there is so much negative gossip, that is difficult to do. But, to set the record straight, I intend to publicly prove, in the manner described below, beyond any doubt that:
Later on in this email I will explain how local people will have the opportunity and power to prove or disprove any of the above statements. In addition, I will also disprove any of the following lies. I have been made aware that certain malicious people have been stating the exact opposite of the above. I have also heard the following lies about me (and I now know the names of those who have engaged in this most often - more about that at the end of this long letter). Comparable lies have most likely been said about many of you. For instance, I have heard that:
Since I am the only person who has ever been expected to contribute money to the foundation, it is obviously NOT a tax scam (unless you consider my receiving a extremely small tax benefit, available to anyone who contributes to anything to any qualified charity, as a tax scam) and even I can't figure out how I might "live off" a foundation that costs me real money every year and gives me little other benefit except the pleasure of helping needy people.
In addition, I will prove with independent physical evidence, that I:
Don't let gossip keep needy people from getting the educational, nutritional, housing, medical, and other help that they (chiefly women and children) critically need. Although our current grantees will continue in the grant program no matter what the future brings, at this moment we also have current unallocated funds for as many as four or five more grantees.
What is the solution?
I will make available for professional verification my entire personal financial situation. How's that for even more transparency than the kind of transparency my Foundation requires of the organizations in this town? I ask for transparency from these organizations as a prerequisite to receiving grants from the MPWCF, although I ask much less than the transparency I now offer regarding my own situation.
In whatever way the residents of this town choose them, I will allow a combined group of 3 USA Certified Public Accountants and/or Canadian Chartered Accountants to volunteer their services to verify the above claims. They shall be restricted by nothing other than their own normal professional and ethical requirements. The aforementioned group of 3 CPAs/CAs may do anything they deem necessary to perform a normal professional verification. The only requirement I have of them is that they publicly present evidence of their professional qualifications and later issue a written and signed "certification" available both to me and to the public of the result of their audit..
What I am going to do if the solution only works partially?
I truly hope that the above offer ends any future gossip on this particular subject, but if it does not, there are alternative means to stop the gossip because I now know the people who are primarily spreading these lies. If I later hear of any gossip that negatively impacts upon the Foundation or me personally, I will assert all of my legal rights and commence prosecution of the offending parties. We in town have talked about slander and defamation far too long without taking the next step. I will take that next step. And the costs of that legal action will be the closest I come to "living off the Foundation" insofar as that money, to be spent on this legal action (unfortunately), will obviously increase the overhead of the Foundation (now only a cumulative total of us$229 in some seven years, including all incorporation and legal fees).
A parting thought, courtesy of Col. Phil Maher (USA consul-agent):
Thanks to Col. Phil Maher - published in Atencion (12/94)
And a last note from me, since the above notice about gossip was in Atencion in 1994, this problem has been around this town for a long, long time.
END QUOTE - the above was written in 2004 -
Please note that while the above public notice caused the persons involved at that time (2004) to cease their defamation, lies once told have a long LONG life. As I said above, I have heard some of the "defaming statements" disclosed above as recently as 2010. Sadly, we had to waste many years and many dollars were not given to deserving organizations who would have otherwise had the additional funds to aid needy children and women of San Miguel.
There is an old related story, equal to the above in its costs to the women and children of San Miguel. As many of you know, all of the profits from the rental of two apartments in my house are currently and annually donated to the MPWCFoundation. It is the gossip calling me a "bad landlord" that has caused a decrease (and finally, a cessation) in such rentals and such donations to the Foundation. Those of you who know me know that I am a man of my word. If I say I will do something, I do it. Apparently a very few of my ex-tenants have not kept their word, especially the written word in the leases (see rental discussion) they agreed to and signed prior to taking occupancy. When I fulfill my obligations under those leases and a tenant does not, I first remind them and if they repeatedly ignore their obligations, I take actions. These are the actions that cause the gossip started by ex-tenants. Apparently they felt that they could conveniently ignore their obligations while receiving the benefits of my fulfillment of my obligations.
I ask you, the reader (or the receiver of such gossip), to assess whether or not there is a possibility of some bias from any person telling you only one side of the story.
There is more about this subject at the very bottom of the Gossip page.